Muted Market Reaction After Strong China PMI Results

Editor’s Note: Jimmy Zhu is a chief strategist at Fullerton Research. The article reflects the author’s opinion, and not necessarily the views of CGTN.

Both China official and Caixin manufacturing PMI exceeded earlier expectations, offering hopes that domestic economy may start picking up from here. Still, price reactions among different markets on Monday sent a message that substantial recovery may be needed.

Official manufacturing PMI was above the key threshold of 50 for the first time since April this year. Still, moves in Shanghai stocks and yuan remained flat in Monday’s trading session while PMIs for medium and small companies remained below 50. The manufacturing PMI for China’s large companies returned back to above 50, however smaller companies continued to struggle.

Domestic demand picking up with some seasonal factors

Prolonged periods of decline in producer prices have eroded manufacturers’ profits, as factory deflation weighed on over the past four months. But relevant indices in PMI last month offered hopes that demand is starting to pick up.

Manufacturing PMI new orders jumped by 1.7 points, the biggest increases since March 2018 to 51.3, while its output PMI index rose 1.8 points to 52.6. Rises in new orders and output indices indicated that deeper declines in producer prices may have paused last month. The pick up in infrastructure projects could be one of the main reasons behind the rising domestic demand. Steel industry PMI rose to 45.4 in November from 41.3 earlier.

However, there was no substantial rise in prices of iron ore and other related industrial metals, which showed that onshore manufacturing activities remained soft. A pick up in manufacturing activities could be largely lifted by seasonal effect, such as some working flows being postponed to November after the national holidays in October. Besides that, some front-loading manufacturing and construction activities might have occured in November due to warm weather last month.

External demands show improving signs, though outlook remains fragile at this stage

Signs of improving external environment also emerged. China new export orders PMI increased by 1.8 points, the biggest increase since April, to 48.8. The moves of the export orders PMI have been in tandem with the Caixin manufacturing PMI, whose survey samples are heavily export-oriented companies focused.

Caixin new export orders slowed modestly from October, but the reading above 50 for a second consecutive month is the first time since March 2018. Many of those participants said both domestic and external demands are improving, according to Caixin.

Chinese major partners’ preliminary manufacturing PMI showed visible improvement as well. Markit eurozone manufacturing PMI jumped 0.7 points, the biggest since November 2017 to 46.6. A similar pattern was also found in the Markit U.S. manufacturing PMI, which jumped 0.9 points to 52.2.

PMIs of Asian countries like Japan, Indonesia, Malaysia and showed a smaller pace of declines. While South Korea’s exports for the first 20 days of November, which is a leading indicator to check the health of the regional economy, fell 9.6 percent. The declines were the least since April this year.

Broad-based improvement in external environment is largely driven by three factors, which are:

1) Hopes of de-escalation on U.S.-China trade tensions in the past two months. Both the U.S. and China said that they are closing to the partial agreement of the trade deal. There is the possibility that trade tensions between the two sides may officially de-escalate for the first time this year if any agreement to be reached this month.

2) Global stock markets are at an all time high, boosting confidence on the real economy. MSCI world equity index jumped by 2.6 percent to 2,293.26 in November, reaching another historic high. There are increasing debates on whether current rally in global stocks justified the fundamentals, but higher prices in equities directly improve the companies’ balance sheet, lifting investors’ and corporates’ confidence on the economic outlook.

3) Earlier synchronized global monetary stimulus that eased companies’ borrowing cost. Monetary policies are not long-term solutions for sustainable growth, but these policies reduce short-term borrowing costs, which in turn reduces the hurdles on companies’ operations.

There are also warning signs that overseas environment remains largely unstable, as uncertainties remain high on these three factors in 2020. Details of the partial deal, which will be crucial in deciding the outlook on trade negotiation in the future still remain unknown at this stage. Outcomes on the partial trade deal are believed to have a significant impact on the global asset prices, including that of stocks and bonds, which may influence the upcoming central banks’ decisions.

(If you want to contribute and have specific expertise, please contact us at

Originally published at on December 2, 2019.



Get the Medium app

A button that says 'Download on the App Store', and if clicked it will lead you to the iOS App store
A button that says 'Get it on, Google Play', and if clicked it will lead you to the Google Play store
Fullerton Markets

Asia’s fastest-growing brokerage firm and disruptive force in the trading industry. Delivers unparalleled fund safety and world-class trading education.